May 21, 2013 11:23 UTC

learningenglish

In Rural India, Medical Myths Spread

TEXT SIZE - +


Download this story as a PDF

This is the VOA Special English Health Report.

Rural areas of India may have few doctors or other health resources. Instead, many people use traditional healers. These faith-based healers, or witch doctors, sometimes have strange theories about how the body works.

In West Bengal, for example, some people have long believed that getting bitten by a dog leads to the birth of puppies. Dr. Kumar Kanti Ghosh is a psychiatrist. He helped document this belief in so-called puppy pregnancy syndrome for an article. It appeared in the Lancet medical journal in two thousand three.

His interest started when a nine-year-old boy came to his health clinic about ten days after being bitten by a dog.

KUMAR KANTI GHOSH: "He believes that he had developed a pregnancy with a puppy inside his abdomen. And sometimes also his parents have said that sometimes the boy is barking like a dog."

A healer named Budheswar Singh says his mixture of yogurt and herbs has cured many people. "If the man is brought to me on time, I can give him my medicine and he will be all right."

Sanjay Samui is a medical doctor who wishes people would stop believing ideas like this. "They are uneducated village people -- they still hold on to such superstitions," he says. He tells everyone that in no situation can a puppy be born inside a human body.

The national government spends about one and a half percent of India's gross domestic product on health care. This is among the lowest rates in the world. It means faith healers are the only choice in some places. The healers spread medical myths and even build distrust against doctors.

But in some countries, doctors may seek help from traditional healers.

Officials in Russia have counted at least eight hundred thousand alternative healers -- more than the number of medical doctors. Daria Minerova, a healer in Moscow, told a reporter last year that doctors often called on her to either cast spells or clear spells for patients. She said they ask her for help when they have a difficult case in trying to cure a patient.

Health care in Russia is basically free. So cost does not explain why people seek alternative healers. Marina Belorysova, a college-educated English teacher in Moscow, told a reporter last year that people avoid western medical care in Russia for a different reason.

MARINA BELORYSOVA: "Medicine is very poor in Russia. It is very bad. At least they know when they use alternative medicine, nothing really bad will happen, right?"

And that's the VOA Special English Health Report. You can find a video about medical myths in rural India at voaspecialenglish.com. I'm Steve Ember.

___

Contributing: Kurt Achin and Jessica Golloher

This forum has been closed.
Comment Sorting
Comments page of 2
    Next 
by: Yoshi
04/20/2012 4:21 AM
Although I believe in psycho-immuno healing system, I am afraid faith-based healing would have patients too late to be treated properly by modern medicine. I am surprised to hear that this kind of non-scientific treatment is still avairable even in an developed country like Russia. The following is just only my inspection. Not all of the Russian doctors are low in medical level, but some medical doctors especially hired as goverment workers have some problems .


by: long
04/08/2012 4:01 AM
In the rural or highland VN, people still cure the disease being the same thing.


by: Prem Verma
04/05/2012 12:16 AM
Its interesting, I live in India but didn't know about this puppy pregnancy myth. Though the rural people use a lot of faith healing technique but in modern India they also go to doctors and use modern developed medical science. This story is about 2003, things have been changed a lot.


by: John Jackson
04/01/2012 7:44 AM
Doctors in Russia make use of healers to cure patents,in severe diseases.


by: Samuel Kim
04/01/2012 7:11 AM
It's amazing that doctors in Russia use healers to cure patients.


by: Simbausa
03/31/2012 11:00 PM
In Vietnam, there was a witch/faith-based obstetric doctor. He used to cure women who cannot give birth forever. He let those women drink his water that he believed it could get women pregnant. It's a miracle those women's abdomen became bigger. But there was a restricted rule that those were not allowed to do ultrasound. After a long time waiting, people suspected him, and this doctor was arrested.


by: Yann
03/30/2012 10:07 AM
I think when we strongly believe that something is healthy,it has really a positive effect on our body,it is the "Placebo effect".


by: Roman
03/29/2012 11:33 AM
The story about puppy pregnancy is very funny. I live in Moscow and I can say that government medical care in Russia is very poor, especially in small towns. People who want to get quality medical care go to private clinics.


by: Ms.Dieu Quynh-TTLady/
03/29/2012 12:01 AM
It's so funny when many Indian people believe that getting bitten by a dog can laed to the birth of puppies. Today, when Science and Technology are getting more and more modern, improving and developing health care system becomes clearly more important.


by: Pikaq
03/28/2012 10:39 PM
If the faith-based do work, the reason would be working from immune system. People believing something in their mind will reinforce their inside power to be successful. The more innocent the faith is, the more power people have. The current or wave from creature no matter what you call its name is mysterious,isn't it.

Comments page of 2
    Next