October 09, 2015 01:31 UTC


The American Civil War: Who Should Memorials Honor?

One group is planting trees to remember the Civil War dead. Others are arguing about whether to rename parks that honor Confederate fighters | AMERICAN MOSAIC

Civil War memorial trees
Civil War memorial trees


Play or download an MP3 of this story
I’m June Simms.
On the show today, we hear music from some of the performers at the South by Southwest music festival in Austin, Texas.
We talk about efforts to remember the many Americans killed in the nation’s Civil War in the 1860s. And we tell about efforts against some of the Civil War memorials that already exist.

Civil War Trees
The Civil War was the bloodiest war in the history of the United States. From 1861 to 1865, at least 620,000 soldiers died in the fighting. It began after several southern states broke away from the North, mainly over the issue of slavery. The southern states declared independence and set up the Confederate States of America, also known as the Confederacy.
Now, 150 years later, a living memorial is being created to honor the war dead. Jim Tedder has more on the project.
The non-profit group Journey through Hallowed Ground is leading the effort. It plans to plant a tree, or recognize an existing tree, for each soldier killed in the war. The memorial will come to life along an almost 300 hundred kilometer road that passes through four states. It will start in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, where the most famous Civil War battle took place. It will end at the Charlottesville, Virginia, home of Thomas Jefferson, America’s third president.
Beth Erickson is with Journey through Hallowed Ground.
“As you see these trees, one after another, it will truly make an impact.”
Oatlands Historic Home and Gardens in Leesburg, VirginiaOatlands Historic Home and Gardens in Leesburg, Virginia
Oatlands Historic Home and Gardens in Leesburg, Virginia
Oatlands Historic Home and Gardens in Leesburg, Virginia

The first trees were planted in November on the grounds of a large, old Virginia home and farm called Oatlands. An historic trust now owns the former plantation. Andrea McGimsey is the Executive Director of Oatlands. She says the former plantation was a good place to start.
“Oatlands has some very old trees and they were here during the civil war time. Many of them are actually going to be adopted as part of the project.”
She adds that Oatlands is a part of Civil War history.
“Oatlands had 128 slaves in 1860, right before the Civil War started. And also the family who lived here had two sons who joined the Confederate Army.”
Richard Williams is a member of the last family to live at Oatlands. His family still owns property next to the home. And they are involved in planting the trees.
“We’re hoping that as private landowners we can also show it’s a great success and encourage some other private landowners.”
Private donations are expected to pay for the 65 million dollar tree planting project. The cost of an individual tree donation is 100 dollars.
The trees will be especially interesting for Smart Phone users. Special markings on the trees can connect users with the stories of individual Civil War soldiers.
Beth Erickson explains.
“These trees will be able to have a number associated with a person. They can use GPS technology to be able to find out who these people were.”
Eleanor Adams has donated a tree in honor of her ancestor Joseph McGowan. He was from Alabama and fought for the South. He was 23 when he was shot and killed. Eleanor Adams says the young soldier wrote letters to his family about life on the battlefield.
“He talks about sickness, the heat in the summertime, the bad food – really a tough time being a soldier in those days.”
She says she hopes other family members will join her in planting trees for other McGowans who died in the Civil War.
Civil War Parks in the South
Other memorials to Civil War forces are currently a subject of dispute. Like parks named after Confederate soldiers.
Nathan Bedford Forrest was a famous fighter for the Confederacy. A park in the city of Memphis, Tennessee, has a statue of him sitting on a horse. The park is named in honor of Forrest, whom many southerners have praised for his defense of the South in the Civil War. Others have criticized his slave-trading past and ties to the secretive Ku Klux Klan.
Nathan Bedford Forrest Park in Memphis TenneseeNathan Bedford Forrest Park in Memphis Tennesee
Nathan Bedford Forrest Park in Memphis Tennesee
Nathan Bedford Forrest Park in Memphis Tennesee

Earlier this week, the Memphis City Council voted to remove Forrest’s name from the park and call it Health Sciences Park. Council members also voted to rename Confederate Park as Memphis Park, and Jefferson Davis Park as Mississippi River Park. The latter was named for a leader of the Confederacy.
The changes have won praise from those who said the Old South is gone. But critics have likened the Council’s actions to rewriting history.
Kenneth Van Buren is a local African-American civil rights activist. He agrees with changing park names tied to the Confederacy. In his words, “how can we have unity in the nation when we have one city, right here in Memphis, which fails to be unified?”
Most of the emotion over the council’s action has involved Nathan Bedford Forrest. Many of his defenders are white. They note his successes as a government official, businessman and military leader. But his critics, white and black, say honoring Forrest celebrates his days as a slave trader and membership in the Ku Klux Klan.
Katherine Blaylock lives in Memphis and opposes the name changes. She says the city has always been racially divided. She accuses city officials of wanting to rewrite history.          
Forrest lived in Memphis before the Civil War. He worked as a cotton farmer and slave trader. He lacked traditional military training, but rose to the position of lieutenant general in the Confederate Army. He became famous for fast horseback raids that broke the Union’s supply line and communications.
Forrest later joined the Ku Klux Klan, which threatened southern blacks. His level of involvement in the Klan is a source of argument. He is believed to have helped break the earliest version of the group in 1869.
Supporters praise him for offering to free 45 of his own slaves if they would serve in the Confederacy. They also say he was unwilling to divide families when he bought slaves.
Forrest died in 1877. His body was moved to Forrest Park in the early 1900s. The park is filled with trees and about the size of a city street. It is just a short distance from the old Lorraine Hotel, where civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. was murdered in 1968.
This is not the first time Forrest Park has led to a heated debate. Memphis officials rejected an effort to rename it in 2005.
The Austin, Texas based music and media festival, South by Southwest opened a few hours ago. The ten-day long festival brings hundreds of artists, entertainers and media interests to town. Christopher Cruise plays music from some of this year’s guests.
That is the band Green Day performing “Oh, Love” from last year’s hit album “Uno.” Green Day is performing at South by Southwest for the first time ever.
Green Day performing in Las Vegas, NevadaGreen Day performing in Las Vegas, Nevada
Green Day performing in Las Vegas, Nevada
Green Day performing in Las Vegas, Nevada

Billie Joe Armstrong and Mike Dirnt formed the band in 1987. They were 15-year-old Californians at the time. Now, the band has eleven albums, five Grammy awards, and three American Music Awards. Their albums have sold millions and millions of copies.
Also performing at South by Southwest this year is the very popular musical team Macklemore and Ryan Lewis. Their song “Thrift Shop” is currently number two on Billboard magazine’s Hot One Hundred singles list.
The American rock band Yeah Yeah Yeahs will also play at the festival this year. Their third and most recent album, “It’s Blitz!” was released in 2009. However, they are expected to release another called “Mosquito” next month. We leave you with the Yeah Yeah Yeahs performing, “Runaway,” from “It’s Blitz.”
This forum has been closed.
There are no comments in this forum. Be first and add one

Learn with The News

  • Photogallery Japanese Rock Band Goes English

    After 10 years of international success, a Japanese rock band records its first album in both its native language and English. They begin performing around the United States this fall. More

  • Audio FIFA Suspends Blatter

    The suspension comes less than two weeks after Swiss attorneys opened a criminal investigation against Blatter. He is charged with possible involvement in a $2 million payment in 2011 to Michel Platini, the head of the Union of European Football Association. More

  • Audio Belarus Writer Gets Nobel Literature Prize

    Svetlana Alexievich of Belarus has won the Nobel Prize in Literature. The Nobel Prize committee in Stockholm, Sweden, called her writings “a monument to suffering and courage in our time." More

  • Audio  US Official: Russian Missiles Aimed at Syria Crash in Iran

    Four Russian cruise missiles fired from a Russian ship crashed in Iran. The cruise missiles were intended to reach Syria. Russia launched its missiles in the Caspian Sea. The Russian Defense Ministry has denied that any of the missiles had fallen short of their targets. More

  • Audio UN Group Calls for Secure Financial Base to World Economy

    The United Nations Conference on Trade and Development deals with trade and development issues. It has called for measures to strengthen international finance including more support for the International Monetary Fund and development banks. More

Featured Stories

  • #aidrefugees

    Audio Top 5 Crowdfunding Projects Ever

    Crowdfunding sites can help start profitable businesses or help people in need. More

  • Video Fabric Fights Dust Mites in Your Bed

    Many people around the world suffer from dust-related allergies. People with allergies have trouble breathing or suffer from tightness in the chest and shortness of breath. Now, scientists in Poland say they have successfully tested cloth that the microscopic creatures cannot pass through. More

  • "Vape," according to the Oxford Dictionaries, is the verb that describes inhaling and exhaling the vapor from an electronic cigarette. It can also be a noun referring to the action or the device.

    Audio Very Low Nicotine Cigarettes May Reduce Addiction

    A new study suggests that selling only cigarettes with very low nicotine levels may actually help people stop smoking. Researchers studied more than 800 smokers. However, cigarette replacements, like e-cigarettes, have not reduced nicotine addiction or tobacco use. More

  • Video Know Your Enemy

    Do you have an enemy? Hopefully, you don’t. An enemy is someone who hates you and you hate them back. An enemy threatens you, attacks you or tries to harm you. In some languages, there are different words for a personal enemy versus an enemy of war, political enemy or enemy of the state. More

  • Audio Everyday Grammar: Comparatives and Superlatives

    When we want to compare things we use comparative and superlative forms. Find out some of rules and exceptions of these important forms in Everyday Grammar for this week. More

Practice Your Writing

Confessions of an English Learner
Confessions of an English Learner blog

Tell us About Our Programs