Accessibility links

Breaking News

Which Is Better for Your Career: Specializing or Generalizing?

People just starting out in the fashion industry may have to do many things, or wear many hats.
People just starting out in the fashion industry may have to do many things, or wear many hats.
Which Is Better for Your Career: Specializing or Generalizing?
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:08:06 0:00

From VOA Learning English, this is the Health & Lifestyle report.

When trying to make a successful career, which is better: being a generalist or a specialist?

In other words, should you generalize and know a little about a lot of things? Or should you specialize and have a deep understanding of only one area?

Well, that depends.

“So, when we think about generalizing versus specializing in our career, we’re really talking about can you do a broad number of tasks versus do you drill down and do one specific thing really well.”

That is Natasha Olinger. Olinger is a human resource expert in Washington, D.C. She talks about the benefits of both. However, the main reason for specializing is an important one: more money.

"So, generally speaking, the common wisdom out there is it’s always better to specialize and that you can demand a higher salary if you specialize.”

To explain her way of thinking, Olinger uses a fairly common situation – choosing a restaurant. Say you want to eat a favorite Japanese meal: sushi.

When you want really good sushi, go to a sushi restaurant. (AP Photo/Shizuo Kambayashi, File)
When you want really good sushi, go to a sushi restaurant. (AP Photo/Shizuo Kambayashi, File)

If you go to a restaurant that only serves sushi, you can expect high quality products, and you also should expect to pay more. If you go to a place that serves sushi, tacos and pizza, the quality of the sushi may not be so great, but the prices will probably be lower. Olinger says the world of work is not all that different.

However, she adds that all is not perfect in the world of the specialist. If there is a drop in economic activity or possibly a recession, a generalist may get more job offers.

“Though it’s generally considered better to be a specialist, the recession of 2008 really showed us that there are times when being a generalist translates to job security even though in boom times being a specialist often leads to a higher salary.”

Size matters

So, are some fields best for generalists and others for specialists? Olinger says the size of the organization can be more important than a sector, or industry.

“I would say the biggest difference -- in terms of, is it better to be a generalist or specialist -- is more the size of the organization, oftentimes, than the sector. So, smaller organizations tend to need more generalists. And larger companies tend to need more specialists. And this is oftentimes regardless of industry.”

So Olinger suggests thinking about the size and type of business you would like to do it for. Small businesses often need people who can do many things. Also, companies that are just getting started often need people who are able to perform many different tasks.

For example, your job description may be that of a graphic designer, but you may also have to do some writing. A person who can do many different things is often called a Jack-of-all-trades and is able to wear many hats.

“I would say, think about the type of organization in which you want to work. If you want to work for a smaller organization or possibly a start-up where, you know, you’re going to have to kind of wear all different kinds of hats...then you would want to focus more on generalizing and learning kind of a broad set of skills.”

Larger companies can be just the opposite. They often need specialists -- experts in a given field. In fact, they may require that you stay in your lane, meaning you do your job and nothing else.

“If you really want to go into a much larger corporation you probably want to specialize. They’re going to be looking for someone who can solve a very specific type of problem that they have. And there probably isn’t going to be as much room or really need to wear all those different hats and kind of pinch hit where needed.”

Know yourself

When planning your career path, the best advice might be to “know yourself.”

Some people like to know a little about a lot of things. They might lose interest in working on the same thing day after day. These people might be happier in a career that lets them perform different duties.

But what if you really love learning everything there is to know about just one subject? You like the idea of being an expert. In that case, it is probably a good idea for you to specialize. However, if you are preparing to specialize in something, you had better make sure that you really like it.

A mix of both may be best

But perhaps the best solution is a mix of generalization and specialization.

Some career planners call this a “T-shaped” career. The top of the T would be the generalized part. The upright stem of the T would be the deeper understanding of a person’s general knowledge – their expertise.

Olinger agrees. She suggests that combining the two may be the best answer.

“I think, ideally, the most successful candidates -- in terms of balancing the ability to demand a higher salary and having their jobs be quote, unquote ‘recession-proof’ -- tend to balance specialized skills with general skills.”

She notes, that a lot depends on where you are in your career. It may be easier to be a generalist when you are younger and then slowly specialize as you get older.

However, experts advise workers to keep their skills up-to-date and be willing to make changes, when needed -- no matter what industry you work in or how old you are.

And that’s the Health & Lifestyle report.

I’m Anna Matteo.

When it comes to work, do you like wearing many hats or do you prefer to drill down into one specific area? Let us know in the Comments Section -- where you can also practice using the expressions from this story.


Quiz - Which Is Better for Your Career: Generalizing or Specializing?

Quiz - Which Is Better for Your Career: Generalizing or Specializing?

Start the Quiz to find out


Words in This Story

versus prep. in contrast to or as the alternative of

broad adj. including or involving many things or people : wide in range or amount

drill downphrasal verb : to look at or examine something in depth

restaurant n. a business establishment where meals or refreshments may be purchased

boom time n. a period in which there is a surge of prosperity for a person, place, or industry

sector n. an area of an economy : a part of an economy that includes certain kinds of jobs

to wear many hats idiomatic expression : to have many jobs or roles

Jack-(or Jill)-of-all tradesidiomatic expression : a person who can do passable work at various tasks : a handy versatile person

stay in your lane idiomatic expression : In the workplace, this expression means to do only what you are responsible for doing.

pinch hit phrasal verb : to act or serve in place of another

expertise n. special skill or knowledge : the skill or knowledge an expert has

quote, unquote - idiomatic expression : used in speech to show that one is exactly repeating someone else's words : sometimes used to show you don't agree with something someone has said : She says they are quote "just good friends" unquote. But it is clear they are dating.